This is great! Everything that has been going through my mind lately and yet another confirmation to my busy thoughts. Thanks!
Modern society is focused on getting you to obsess over your most basic needs and some Christians want to push you that direction too. Preachers who preach the prosperity gospel tend to dumb down God and undersell his great care for us. I don’t think most Christians would argue that he wants to provide for us. We all recognize that he wants to lavish great gifts on his children. Passages like those in Deuteronomy 28 describe how “it pleases God to make you prosper.”
We know intuitively that if you love someone, you will help meet their needs. The real question with prosperity gospel preachers is, “What constitutes a need?” If I’m hungry, and if you’re someone who loves me, you may prepare a great feast for me and I may honor you by eating until I’m full.
But suppose I stay at that buffet table well beyond the time of fullness, to the point of gorging and gluttony, and suppose that every time we meet thereafter, I’m looking for you to give me more food. Where’s the love in that?
The human need for food is the most basic of human needs. Maslow defines four higher order needs beyond that: Security, Belonging, Esteem, and the highest need, Actualization – the need to use your gifts in a useful way.
If I protect you and give you a nice 401k, I’ve still just addressed your second most basic need – your need for security. What kind of prosperity is that? You’ve still got unmet higher level needs.
Prosperity gospel preachers who talk a lot about money and the stuff it buys have a lot in common with an employer who pays you well at a job you don’t enjoy. Both address your two most basic needs for provision and protection, but do little to meet your higher order needs for belonging to a group, especially with people that value you, and for your need to contribute to a cause that is bigger than you.
Prosperity has to do with meeting all your needs and coming fully alive. It explains how a woman like Mother Teresa can have so little, yet have so much. True prosperity has nothing to do with cars, jewelry, or perceived status. All that stuff does is feed your small-minded ego and its fixation on lower order needs.
Thanks Seth for this reminder. I think the most insidious malady these days is one where someone privately is passionate to accumulate and create personal financial security while in public promoting the cause of orphans, prisoners, widows and the afflicted at the expense of something “real”. That disease is far too common and spreading.
Personally I’d rather share company with an avowed capitalist where money is their God than someone stirring a broth both bitter and sweet.
That’s something I’m writing about.
By the way congratulations on Talia’s news…I am excited for this new dispensation in your life, Karen’s and hers. She will be a wonderful wife, mother and model to others.
I agree with Butch; let’s be honest and true to our convictions (even if we don’t agree with them).
My happiness comes from spending time with family, serving, and simple things and being open to God’s direction and teaching which admittedly currently has me on a rather steep and uncomfortable curve.
Letting my yes be yes and my no be no and getting rid of the lukewarm and people pleasing.
The paradox of happiness is that I am most fulfilled when I am least concerned about my prosperity and intently focused on the betterment of others. Great post, Seth.
Thanks, Connie and Jeff. Walking out my salvation with something that occasionally looks like fear and trembling.
Reading this came at the perfect time as I am obsessing over finding some good American comfort foods, and maybe a hot shower from time to time! But God is standing right in front of me, offering me so much more right now.
Good word pop’s!
See you at debrief!
This is a great reminder. I think I feel my happiest when I’m living in community with others and really connecting with people. What’s really nice is to have a mentor who has similar gifts as yourself who can disciple you in using those gifts for the Lord and the Kingdom.
Subscribe to Radical Living:
Receive updates on the latest posts as Seth Barnes covers many topics like spiritual formation, what if means to be a christian, how to pray, and more. Radical Living blog is all about a call to excellence in ministry, church, and leadership -as the hands and feet of Jesus.